Monaco Journal - Calgary Councillors Warn of Millions in Costs as Alberta Bill Targets Bike Lanes

NYSE - LSE
CMSC 0.16% 19.11 $
GSK -1.59% 47.82 $
BCC -2.07% 64.38 $
BCE -3.42% 21.33 $
BTI -1.79% 57.47 $
RIO -1.61% 74.7 $
BP -0.09% 43.21 $
NGG -1.68% 80.86 $
RYCEF 1.2% 17.57 $
CMSD 0.11% 18.8 $
RBGPF 0% 75.3 $
JRI -1.31% 10.71 $
RELX -0.49% 38.83 $
AZN -1.91% 175.41 $
VOD -2.84% 14.44 $
Calgary Councillors Warn of Millions in Costs as Alberta Bill Targets Bike Lanes
Calgary Councillors Warn of Millions in Costs as Alberta Bill Targets Bike Lanes

Calgary Councillors Warn of Millions in Costs as Alberta Bill Targets Bike Lanes

Calgary city councillors have warned that the Alberta government’s proposed legislation to restrict or remove bike lanes could cost the city millions of dollars. The criticism follows the introduction of Bill 43, which grants provincial authority over municipal cycling infrastructure and has drawn sharp rebuke from local officials regarding fiscal responsibility and municipal autonomy.

Text size:

Calgary city councillors have warned that the Alberta government’s proposed legislation to restrict or remove bike lanes could cost the city millions of dollars. The criticism follows the introduction of Bill 43, known as the Safe and Sensible Roads Act 2026, which grants provincial authority over municipal cycling infrastructure and has drawn sharp rebuke from local officials regarding fiscal responsibility and municipal autonomy.

The legislation, introduced by the Alberta government, includes provisions that would allow the province to intervene in the delivery of bike lanes in provincial municipalities. According to the bill’s framework, clear rules would be established for municipal bike lanes that reduce road capacity, potentially restricting their creation. The act could also permit the restoration of bike lanes to motor-vehicle use during road repaving or resurfacing projects and enable the removal of existing bike lanes deemed to reduce road capacity.

Devin Dreeshen, Alberta’s Minister of Transportation and Economic Corridors, stated that the legislation aims to ensure transportation infrastructure serves all road users based on data. "We’ve heard concerns from Albertans that some bike lanes reduce existing road capacity and parking, increase congestion, and hinder the efficient movement of emergency vehicles," Dreeshen said. He added that the bill would allow the province to restrict or remove bike lanes that reduce road capacity for motor vehicles.

The provincial government opened a complaint portal earlier this year to collect grievances from citizens unhappy with bike lanes in their communities. In response to questions regarding the implementation of the new rules, Minister Dreeshen said the province would work with Calgary and Edmonton to collect data on specific roads identified as alleged problem routes. He emphasized that the province supports bike lanes in appropriate corridors, such as light rail transit (LRT) right-of-ways, utility right-of-ways, and public land.

"Getting all that data with those individual bike lanes will be step one, and then from there, we’ll be working with the municipalities to make sure that if that bike lane doesn’t actually cut the mustard, it doesn’t actually make sense to that community, then that’s something that we’ll be able to remove with them," Dreeshen said.

The City of Calgary stated that it provided the province with information over the summer regarding data on bike lane infrastructure, including traffic impacts, safety benefits, and overall usage. In an email response, the city noted that since providing this data, it has not received further formal requests related to the new legislation.

When questioned about the costs associated with removing already installed bike lanes, Dreeshen stated that cities would bear those expenses, which would ultimately be shouldered by municipal property taxpayers. He suggested that the most cost-effective method for removal would be during road repaving projects. "That’s why we want to work with both Edmonton and Calgary to make sure that we can do this in the best way for taxpayers," he said.

However, the City of Calgary confirmed that money for potential bike lane removals was not included in the upcoming proposed four-year budget. This omission highlights the financial uncertainty facing the municipality if the province enforces its new powers.

Ward 8 Councillor Nathan Schmidt criticized the legislation as adding layers of bureaucracy to a province that claims to want to cut red tape. He argued that the bill creates a process where municipalities must seek approval for actions they have managed for over a decade. "They’re putting this into a process where we have to check with our parents every time we’re going to do anything, and so much control is going into the hands of the minister, where our hands are functionally tied to do work that we’ve been doing for over a decade now," Schmidt said.

Schmidt also expressed concern about the specific costs associated with removing infrastructure. He pointed to 26 Avenue SW in Calgary as an example of a street identified by Dreeshen as a concern. Schmidt noted that the overall project cost $23 million, with approximately $2 million related to the bike lanes on that stretch. While no traffic lanes were removed, some street parking was eliminated.

"It came with utility upgrades. It came with sidewalk improvements, some additions of trees, some new signage," Schmidt said. "So, if they tell us that we need to rip this up, then some of that other work is going to have to be redone, and that is going to come at a big cost for something that is effectively brand new."

Ward 5 Councillor Raj Dhaliwal criticized the lack of engagement with cities before the legislation was rolled out. He described the move as an example of the province using an "iron fist" with municipalities on issues that do not align with the United Conservative Party’s ideology. Dhaliwal also highlighted a perceived hypocrisy, noting that while the province complains about federal interference in provincial matters, it is intervening heavily in municipal affairs.

Addressing the financial aspect of potential removals, Dhaliwal argued that taxpayers should not bear the cost of reversing previous investments. "Here’s the thing: if they want to rip out those bike lanes, well, guess what? Be my guest, but pay for it because Calgary taxpayers have already paid for it," Dhaliwal said. "Many of them may not like it, but that’s money invested. If you’re going to uninvest that, you’ve got to pay for it."

The debate underscores a growing tension between provincial policy goals and municipal implementation realities. As the province moves forward with data collection and potential interventions, Calgary officials remain focused on the financial implications and the erosion of local decision-making power.

P.Dubois--MJ